Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    SweetCrudeReportsSweetCrudeReports
    Subscribe
    • Home
    • Oil
    • Gas
    • Power
    • Solid Minerals
    • Labour
    • Financing
    • Freight
    • Community Development
    • E-Editions
    SweetCrudeReportsSweetCrudeReports
    Home » Blow for activists as UK court dismisses Shell climate case

    Blow for activists as UK court dismisses Shell climate case

    July 25, 2023
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp

     

    London — Environmental law charity ClientEarth’s unsuccessful attempt to sue Shell over its climate strategy shows the difficulties in bringing activist shareholder claims, lawyers said on Monday, after London’s High Court dismissed the case.

    ClientEarth, which holds 27 shares in Shell, alleges the company cannot achieve its aim of net zero carbon emissions by 2050 with its current climate transition strategy and its directors are therefore breaching their duties to shareholders.

    The group wanted to bring a so-called derivative case on behalf of Shell against its directors, which could have seen other firms face investors’ lawsuits over climate-related risks.

    However, Judge William Trower refused permission to bring the case. He ruled that ClientEarth’s case ignored that managing large businesses requires directors to “take into account a range of competing considerations”, in which courts should not interfere.

    A Shell spokesperson welcomed the ruling and described ClientEarth’s case as “fundamentally flawed”.

    Paul Benson, a senior lawyer at ClientEarth, said the charity was disappointed and intended to pursue an appeal.

    Teja Pisk, a lawyer at Stevens & Bolton, said the ruling was unsurprising given the high bar for bringing a derivative claim.

    But, Pisk added, the decision “will not sound the death knell” for shareholder activism in the environmental, social and governance (ESG) sphere.

    Catherine Gilfedder, a partner at law firm Dentons, said ClientEarth’s defeat “re-emphasises the challenges involved in derivative actions in this area”.

    But she also said she thought there would be further cases based on directors’ duties and responsibilities, both in Britain and elsewhere.

    Elaina Bailes, a partner at law firm Stewarts, noted that the judge had accepted Shell’s argument that ClientEarth brought the case to further its own policy agenda.

    “That is potentially significant for the future use of shareholder claims alleging breach of directors duties,” she said.

    The ruling may, however, provide useful guidance to activists considering future claims over directors’ duties and boards’ approaches to climate change, Bailes added.

    Reporting by Sam Tobin Editing by Kylie MacLellan and Mark Potter – Reuters

    Follow us on twitter

    Related News

    Angola’s Block 17 partners sign license extension

    Tinubu pardons Ken Saro-Wiwa, confers national honours on Ogoni Nine

    NCDMB Executive Secretary becomes member of APPO Board

    E-book
    Resilience Exhibition

    Latest News

    “We want reparations”, oil-affected Niger Delta victims demand action

    June 13, 2025

    Transocean Coatings establishes affiliate at SIIFZ

    June 13, 2025

    LASG approves seven dedicated truck parks for Lekki Port axis

    June 13, 2025

    NCDMB Executive Secretary joins AEW 2025 amid focus on enhancing local capacity

    June 13, 2025

    AfDB to provide $184.1m for Africa’s largest solar energy and battery storage project

    June 13, 2025
    Demo
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    • Opec Daily Basket
    • Oil
    • Power
    • Gas
    • Freight
    • Financing
    • Labour
    • Technology
    • Solid Mineral
    • Conferences/Seminars
    • Community Development
    • Nigerian Content Initiative
    • Niger-Delta Question
    • Insurance
    • Other News
    • Focus
    • Feedback
    • Hanging Out With Markson

    Subscribe for Updates

    Get the latest energy news from Sweetcrudereports.

    Please wait...
    Please enter all required fields Click to hide
    Correct invalid entries Click to hide
    © 2025 Sweetcrudereports.
    • About Us
    • Advertise with us
    • Privacy Policy

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.